Subject: Breed Specific Legislation
(BSL) “Dangerous” breed dogs in
For the attention to: Abdullah Gül the
My name is Mariano Peinado and for me is a
great honor to contact with you if you allow it to
me. I am writing to you from
I have the honour to be the president of the INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR DEFENCE CANINE AND HIS RESPONSIBLE OWNERS (IADCRO). For me is a great honour to write to you in the name of all IADCRO´S Members and the animal rights lovers distributed around the world which endorse our work. I send you this information for your amiable consideration.
In IADCRO we are people with more of 40 years inside of dogs. IADCRO is composing by professional technicians around the dog like for example; ethology scientists people, naturalistic, veterinary, university professors specialized in genetics, breeders, trainers, biologists, etc.
The reason to communicate with you, is for to give you and your executive team some suggestions if you allow us, of course, we would tell you that in our humble opinion about the breeds dogs banned in Turkey, the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Japanese Tosa, Dogo Argentino and the Fila Braziliero, showing to us their malaise and preoccupation by their doggies which are considered member of their own families same people of your country.
The information that I come to provide to you, comes from several professional sectors of the canine union of several countries, that show their opinion under the experience acquired in the course of theirs lives, about the existence or not existence of “Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous” breed dogs. The professionals more remarkable than guarantee this information, are those that are more than enabled to advise to the executive, with respect to the existence or not of Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous breed dogs and it has not considered to them to advise, I talk about the information that the ethology scientists people provide to us. The ethology scientists people, are the scientific professionals more indicated and better qualified to talk and to advise about the American Pit Bull Terrier (APBT) and the others breed dogs, since they have studied during many years the character and behavior of the APBT and its surroundings.
Ethology is the science that studies the behavior of the free animal and, when it does with domestic animals (as it is the case of the dog) realises it since the approach of applied Ethology. Several ethology scientists people of different countries, have declared publicly from point of view scientific, that none breed dog are not a dangerous, nor the American Pit Bull Terrier for being the worse breed dog considered between the rest of breed dogs, is not either a dangerous breed dog, is a breed dog like any other within species canine and that everything will depend by all means for the dog will be dangerous or no, on the surroundings in which it grows up, and on the education that received by its owner, unique person in charge of the damages who could make his animal, like the father is it with his minor son. Also the ethology scientists people emphasize, the nonconvenience of classifying or of cataloguing breed dogs in negative way, so that it goes to the detriment of this marvellous and noble breed dogs and it confused to the citizens, to the point to even cause an unwarranted social alarm, quite harmful in several aspects for the own society.
In the FIRST INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF IADCRO, it has been demonstrated scientifically by the ethology scientists, the nonexistence of Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous breed dogs. This demonstrated scientifically is Ok and validated for all the countries. http://www.iadcro.com/informationcongress.html
Association for the Study of the Dog and its Surroundings () http://www.aepe.net
Mr. Antonio Pozuelos President (AEPE) and one of the higher recognized ethology scientist people of international scope, In our opinion he is the most recognized, not only by the knowledge and experience that owns in almost the 40 years studying the dogs daily of all breed dogs, also by his human quality. http://www.aepe.net
In order to resist the information that I make arrive to you, your Government team also can contact with infinity of ethology scientists people through the following electronic direction: http://www.fiapbt.net/etologia2.html
I have provided our research data on the bite stats
for several Cities and countries further in this correspondence, because is
good idea for to open eyes to incredulous and sceptical people, so we think that would be a good idea that would not be to discriminate
and to catalogue breed dogs like Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous, only would
should be to describe in the Law to
the Potentially Dangerous dog like individual and by his activities of behavior, independently the size without giving importance
if the dog is of one or the other breed dog or mixed dog. Also we think that would be a good idea to
describe in the Law to the owner
irresponsible of dog, for this way fomenting and teaching to be good responsible owners of dog and to describe in the Law too, the activities
realised with dogs contemplated like crime, like for example it could be the
organized fights with dogs or other activities in which mistreats or the life
of the dog is put in risk.
Our thinking is that all breeds can be dangerous or none, that the only means to identify what is or is not a dangerous dog like individual is by his behaviour and not by his breed.
Some countries that had adopted negative Laws against American Pit Bull Terrier and others breed dogs, but since many years ago and not of now, concretely since the year 1991 as it is the case of England, in 1993 the case of Holland, Italy, Bermuda, etc. After to have studied the Governments of this Countries the information that from IADCRO we made them arrive at the same time and, to the salary verified by their own eyes the inefficiency of this type of Laws that criminalizes and excludes American Pit Bull Terrier and others breed dogs of their corresponding countries, included/understood the total inefficiency of the Law when not offering security to their citizens, since the statistics of attacks of dogs to people of his country indicated that not only it had not been reduced the attacks, quite the opposite, had been increased the attacks and the deaths although to have excluded American Pit Bull Terrier and the others breed dogs of all their national territory, since the attacks were produced by dogs of any breed dogs and its mixed.
The governors of these countries, understood the necessity of the creation of a Law that did not name “Dangerous or Potentially Dangerous” breed and the correct way is foment and teach to be a RESPONSIBLE dog owner, without mattering if them were American Pit Bull Terrier owners or a Cocker owners, because a Cocker into the hands of an IRRESPONSIBLE owner, also can bring about deaths of people, not only by accidents of traffic when trying to run over to the animal, also by the mortal bit that can cause these dogs of small size to young children, which although are young are people also as all we know.
We are very glad when we can read in the news that the Government people of these Countries told in public that the BSL don´t work and is not good for the security of the citizens:
1 - Annulled the Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) “Dangerous breed dogs” by its inefficiency in
I give to your executive team all the papers regarding Pit Bull Law Holland.
The Report of the Committee of
Wise led to the amendment of the law. This report was an investigation into the
actual number of breeds of dog bite incidents. It was clear that the American Pit bull Terrier is not in the top 3.
I send you the links so you these documents in your possession. Here you can find all documents that led to the creation of legislation and the abolition. These are all Parliamentary documents of the
The report which led to the amendment of the Law can be found here Pitbull "Dog Bites in better perspective: http://www.box.net/shared/iqj110lfxp
Also I would like you to give the link to the movie channel at youtube: http://www.youtube.com/givenchy2007?gl=NL&hl=nl
In that video you can find the movies from the first American Pit Bull Terrier shows in the
2 - Annulled the Breed Specific
Legislation (BSL) “Dangerous breed dogs” by its inefficiency in
3 - Annulled the Breed Specific Legislation
(BSL) “Dangerous breed
dogs” by its inefficiency in
4 - Annulled the Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) “Dangerous breed dogs” by its inefficiency in
“To rectify it is of wise people” and this attitude, the citizens values it and is thankful for it.
The breed dogs does not make bad dogs, is the people (Irresponsible and bad owners) that make it that way. Then the problem, We think would be due to take a cut from the root, condemning to the irresponsible owners of dog, instead of condemning some breed dogs.
The people that are banned the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Japanese Tosa, Dogo Argentino and the Fila Braziliero, in all the territory of Turkey, when happened a time under this prohibit Law and by their own experience verify that the attacks of dogs to people instead to be reduced the real thing is that the attacks of dogs to people were increased, by the ineffective of this Law, then What do they will do? Be eliminating more breed dogs one in one until reaching more that the 400 existing breed dogs and that are equipped with a physically strength even to kill an adult and strong man? And with the crossings of all these 400 breed dogs, What do they will do? so that the crossings of these more 400 breed dogs also are more than enabled even to physically to kill an adult and strong man. We know that it is a difficult question.
And with almost of the 200 breed dogs that although are not enabled to physically to kill an adult and strong man, they are enabled for kill of small children, What are going to make then with these almost 200 small breed dogs, would eliminate also them one by one? And its crossings? We know that it is a difficult question too. The small children are people also, in addition they are those that more undergo the attacks of the dogs and those that pass away more in these unfortunate accidents, which by the way are not American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Japanese Tosa, Dogo Argentino and the Fila Braziliero, but so that the news runs as the powder and is saleable for the hearing, one names almost always to that five breed dogs as the cause of the attack to people, and this is not true. Therefore, enough people think that only this five breed dogs is the cause of the attacks to the people
The honourable people that are banned these five noble breed dogs in
Not only attacks five breed dogs, attack all the breed dogs and their crossings if they are in irresponsible hands. Or all the breed dogs and their crossings are dangerous or none. In IADCRO we thought that no breed dog is dangerous or potentially dangerous. We think that the cause for the dogs attack the human, everything is going to depend on the control, education and responsibility that offers the owner to his dog and is in this indeed, where the Law must thoroughly have applied. These five breed dogs, which indeed the are being used to realise all type of social workings for benefit of the humanity, like for example:
By all that, the American Pit Bull Terrier, Officially Certificated in the year 2000 the breed dog as “HUMANITY BENEFICIAL BREED DOG”. Since IADCRO, FIAPBT and others Institutions, Clubs, Associations around the dogs, we endorsed and we supported this positive cataloguing without doubt to the breed dog American Pit Bull Terrier, for being deserving of her and to be the worst breed dog considerate of all breed dogs in this subject.
We put to the American Pit Bull Terrier of example, for be the worse considered and mistreated breed of all the five criminalized breeds, so that you understand the error to consider badly any breed dogs. Criminalizing breeds is the ruin and the extinction of the breed and like rational people that we are the humans, we would have to make the opposite.
To remember that the dogs have been always from the beginnings of the humanity, the best friend of the man, facilitating to us company, security and food for can to eat day to day for our survival.
We can observe, that in some countries where some breed dogs were catalogued like “Potentially Dangerous”, the attacks of dogs to people with the spend of the years after to be implanted the Breed Specific Legislation (BSL) “Dangerous” breed dogs” the attacks of dogs to people not only did not fall, unfortunately were increased and by breed dogs that are not considered " Dangerous", as always it had been ocurred. Of it has comes the disappointment from many ex-owners of dogs in owning dogs, when they at the time acquired dogs of breeds catalogued like very good and helpful, used even like dogs for blind people, like they are the Labrador Retriever, Golden Retriever, Collie, etc. and could verify in his own meats, that these dogs educated incorrectly were very dangerous with the adult and young people. For this reason from IADCRO we suggest, that the Law would not must to discriminating and criminalizing breeds dogs and yes, would be needed to foment and teaching to be a responsible owner of dog, indifferently the breed that the Turkey dog owners have.
Acting in this sens Abdullah Gül, in our opinion will be able to offer a greater protection and security to the citizens and at the same time, also a greater protection to the dogs would be provided.
All IADCRO´S Members and the animal rights lovers distributed around the world and endorse our work, we would be very much thankful to you Sir President, if you and your Government Team would can considered our information of this letter, for that theTosa, Dogo Argentino and the Fila Braziliero, stops being prohibited in your country but yes, American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Japanese
In IADCRO we are to your whole disposition for help if you will need to us.
Best kind of regards.
- In the next Link contains studies of the effects that prohibitive laws have on the population concerning, and it contains documents with guidelines to the legislators, so they can legislate in a fare way. It was proven by NAIA that every time that people get restrictions about dog ownership, the society becomes more vulnerable and feels more unsafe.
We put to the American Pit Bull Terrier Links of example, for be the worse considered and mistreated breed of all the five criminalized breeds, so that you understand the error to consider badly any breed dogs;
- The dogs are aggressive if they receive a bad
education and not by its breed. Investigation in the